OIC-SEMANTIC-PROMOTION-001: promote Gate-G-validated bounded reference implementation - #40
Merged
Merged
Conversation
Release-state finalization for the OIC-SEMANTIC-PROMOTION-001 candidate. Records the scoped independent Gate F repository validation result for the exact candidate c0108a7 (tree 1d12b17) in the two front doors and in the capability matrix, and enforces it in the code-start gate and the contract tests. The recorded result is explicitly scoped to reproducibility, boundary integrity, the specified fail-closed properties, packaging and the named adversarial checks for that candidate only. All twelve exclusions are retained verbatim: semantic correctness, model accuracy, institutional validity, legal effect, provider qualification, rights resolution, ontology execution, production compilation, runtime authorization, institutional-IR closure, enterprise readiness and benchmark superiority. Ceilings are unchanged: the production semantic gate remains BLOCKED, NVIDIA remains NOT_QUALIFIED, Canada redistribution remains UNRESOLVED, Ontology 007R1 remains unexecuted and execution-unauthorized, the negative-stability live outcome remains DEFERRED, and no production compilation or runtime authorization is established. Gate G and owner merge authorization remain pending. No merge is authorized by this commit. The gate now refuses a forged, mutated or removed independent-validation evidence record, and the claims-discipline contract fails closed if STATUS.md drops the validation statement or escalates beyond the scoped result. No semantic runtime, demo, fixture, package-data, dependency, manifest, evidence or frozen-experiment path is changed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_0182Rv5rUF6BQbvZXReWW4ck
inventor1975
approved these changes
Sep 6, 2026
inventor1975
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Sep 7, 2026
BASE ADVANCED AFTER FREEZE — SUCCESSOR RECONCILIATION. Not a defect in 8f32e53: that commit remains valid as the historical APPLY-001A state and is preserved as this merge's first parent. No rebase, no amend, no force-push. Parents: - 8f32e53 frozen APPLY-001A state (OIC/ZTL maturation rebase) - 8ebac66 main after PR #41, "Acknowledge validated post-merge OIC state" Conflict: README.md and STATUS.md, on the same lines both changes touch. Resolution. PR #41 did not merely replace the pre-merge wording; it added a fail-closed guard (STALE_PRE_MERGE_PHRASES in tests/contract/test_claims_discipline.py) against reintroducing it, and requires the front door to carry exact Gate G anchors read from the live capability matrix. The earlier instruction to keep the stale sentence alive under a dated supersession is therefore withdrawn as incompatible with the new main, and the historical state is preserved by git history and PR #41 rather than by a false line in the current front door. Kept from #41: Gate G PASS, the PR #40 merge fact, exact candidate/tree/merge anchors, ceilings and exclusions, absence of stale pre-merge phrases, and the new anti-staleness controls. Kept from #42: the two matured sides and the missing semantic middle; bounded candidate admission; provisional interpretation; current ZTL maturity; ZTL RUNTIME ATTACHMENT = BLOCKED; the three absent transitions; links to the maturation, layer-ownership, current-state and DARPA documents; the claim ceiling; tier_1_reproduction = NOT ESTABLISHED. Two statements of ours became objectively false through #41 and were corrected, nothing else was touched: - "The section below says a merge remains pending" — it no longer does. - the heading "Current status (historical — superseded)" was labelling #41's current Gate G text as historical. Restored to "Current status". Unchanged, deliberately: docs/contracts/kernel-profiles/ztl-v0.1.json, every ADR, src/oic/**, schemas/**. No ZTL representation added to CAPABILITY_MATRIX; the representation gap stands as a result, and #41's Gate G promotion evidence is accepted as the new base state. KILL-Z8 and KILL-Z9 remain OPEN / UNGUARDED. Validation after merge: repository gate PASS; 1731 passed, 1 declared skip, 1 workstation lock-drift failure that is not an OIC failure. No repository failures. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Promotion of the Gate-G-validated candidate under owner-authorized work order
OIC-PR-PROMOTION-001. No repository content is changed by this pull request beyond the branch as already validated: the head commit and tree are exactly the objects independent Gate G examined.main:9ad37fc80d8f34318c6212ed702de5eab3551cf5oic-weekly-convergence-2026-09-03:a2b5053771ce510fb35ce09f3e99f545c21ac20eb8e31ec4786a2fd1aca976a6ff047deeee63ef15Customer problem and requirements
OIC-SEMANTIC-PROMOTION-001bounded reference implementation has completed independent Gate F and Gate G validation on the feature branch and needs to reachmainwithout any departure from the validated tree.BLOCKED.Scope
src/oic(admission, candidate extraction, interpretation proposal, review docket, model provider, frozen synthetic provider),scripts/verify_code_start_gate.py,scripts/falsify_infrastructure.py,scripts/demo_bounded_semantic_path.py, contract and unit tests, admission-boundary design and schema artifacts, benchmark fixtures, docs and packaging metadata.COPY_EXACTprovenance results are carried from frozen source3fcdec63b7e546d9b369e0e8664d5d67be6a3b54and are recorded per-path indocs/capabilities/CAPABILITY_MATRIX.json.Verification
tests/contract/test_canada_acquisition_preflight.py:574(gitignored local receipts intentionally unavailable in CI).make verifyandmake falsifyboth pass, the latter observing 4/4 expected falsification checks. Ruff check and format check, strict mypy and the repository credential scan all pass.benchmarks/demo/bounded-semantic-pathand the characterization corpora v0.3–v0.5. No real corpus was fetched and no provider was invoked.OIC-INDEPENDENT-GATE-G-001(GATE_G_PASS), which verified identity and boundary, audited the shipped claims, ran eight adversarial mutation challenges, and executed the full canonical Linux sequence against this exact head. Two offline demo runs, executed in a network namespace with no interfaces and with credentials stripped, were byte-identical with empty stderr and hashed to0f9d01bb0dfc488505e027ac7bd8aecf869578e379b5a977cd9d642f2101a39a. Wheel build, clean external-venv install,pip check, package-data verification and import/CLI smoke all pass.mainat9ad37fc80d8f34318c6212ed702de5eab3551cf5is the pre-merge state and is a strict ancestor of this head, so no history rewrite is needed to restore it.Risk
SOURCE_MANIFEST.csvis unchanged and remains explicitly INCOMPLETE.requirements/dev.txtand installed with--require-hashes;pip checkreports no broken requirements. CI actions are pinned to immutable commit SHAs.Claims and limitations
c0108a7a80585d6f5732407d4904ba815073ecd2(tree1d12b17aad7977c939090909171183be166cfd50), explicitly scoped to reproducibility, boundary integrity, the specified fail-closed properties, packaging and named adversarial checks for that candidate only.NOT_QUALIFIED; Canada redistribution remainsUNRESOLVED; Ontology 007R1 remains unexecuted and execution-unauthorized; the negative-stability live outcome remainsDEFERRED; production compilation, runtime authorization and institutional-IR closure remainUNESTABLISHED; the production semantic gate remainsBLOCKED.Note on repository state: the README and STATUS wording in this tree is the pre-merge wording that Gate G validated. A post-merge repository-state acknowledgment is deliberately out of scope here and is a separate authorized work order; editing those files in this PR would depart from the validated tree.
Generated by Claude Code