Problem & intent
Replace codex exec review with argus-review at every point doperpowers names a review METHODOLOGY: the reviewing-prs loop engine (skills/reviewing-prs/scripts/review-engine.sh + the worker protocol around it) and the execplan final-branch exit-gate (skills/execplan/SKILL.md), plus documentation prose. Child C4 of docs/doperpowers/specs/2026-07-26-claude-review-stack-roadmap.md.
Constraints
- Consumes X1 (bench + bar) and X2 (headless mechanism proven by C1.G3); names the minimum argus-review version it requires.
- Non-review codex uses (triage worker, codex-spawn substrate) are OUT of scope — standing exclusion.
- Bench decision rule (roadmap Risks): if the side-by-side bench fails the X1 bar, ONE retry with the auto-routed default effort raised; still failing → park needs-human with the numbers (iterate-C2 / ship-anyway / abandon is the human's call).
Success criteria
- G1: a dispatched PR review on the live loop runs argus as its engine, and the X1 side-by-side bench (argus vs codex engine) passes the bar.
- G2: execplan's exit-gate and reviewing-prs docs name argus first; codex at most as fallback.
Open questions
- Engine-contract shape for the argus invocation (compact findings file, bounded wait, event stream?) — child's grill, seeded by C1.G3's probe findings.
Decision log
- Covers the execplan exit-gate, not just the loop (roadmap Decision Log — leaving it on codex would contradict the unit's purpose).
Problem & intent
Replace
codex exec reviewwith argus-review at every point doperpowers names a review METHODOLOGY: the reviewing-prs loop engine (skills/reviewing-prs/scripts/review-engine.sh+ the worker protocol around it) and the execplan final-branch exit-gate (skills/execplan/SKILL.md), plus documentation prose. Child C4 ofdocs/doperpowers/specs/2026-07-26-claude-review-stack-roadmap.md.Constraints
Success criteria
Open questions
Decision log