Some apps crashes with Vector enabled

[drandrew1983]

Steps to reproduce/复现步骤

1.rooted pixel 10 pro with KSU next LKM
2. Install zygisk next
3. install vector and restart
4. Install HSBC US app from Google play store
5. Open the HSBC US app and it will immediately crash

Expected behaviour/预期行为

The app should open and show the screen to log in

Actual behaviour/实际行为

Crashes all the time

Xposed Module List/Xposed 模块列表

All modules were disabled for troubleshooting

Root implementation/Root 方案

KSU next LKM

System Module List/系统模块列表

All disabled and enabled one by one till I discovered that Vector is causing the crash

LSPosed version/LSPosed 版本

Latest GitHub actions debug version build 3035

Android version/Android 版本

16

Version requirement/版本要求

• I am using the latest debug build from GitHub Actions./我正在使用 GitHub Actions 中最新的调试版本。

Logs/日志

Vector-v2.0-3035-Debug.zip

[drandrew1983]

I found out that your module neozygisk works fine with Vector and my apps are not crashing anymore
I guess that vector doesn't work well with zygisk next...
For now I'm using your module neozygisk...
You can close my issue if you're not planning to fix that

[JoakimCh]

I used it with the latest Magisk inbuilt Zygisk and had Ice Box crash:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.catchingnow.icebox

You should try to figure out why this happens instead of only being compatible with NeoZygisk? But for now I'll try again with that and see if it works... Feel free to reopen issue if you want to resolve this.

Edit: That didn't work either.

[drandrew1983]

unfortunately this issue started to reappear again for unknown reasons, yet on my other pixel phone the same app with the same modules work fine... it's very strange and the only other solution that worked now is enabling unmount modules in KSU for the app that crashes...
I hope jingmatrix would look into the issue

[JingMatrix]

@drandrew1983 This is not an issue of Vector at all, you should understand how basic detection works.
Please read the README of NeoZygisk to understand the traces of system modules: https://github.com/JingMatrix/NeoZygisk .

Most importantly, the section https://github.com/JingMatrix/NeoZygisk?tab=readme-ov-file#configuration explictly tells you that you must have Umount modules option on to clean traces.

[drandrew1983]

@drandrew1983 This is not an issue of Vector at all, you should understand how basic detection works. Please read the README of NeoZygisk to understand the traces of system modules: https://github.com/JingMatrix/NeoZygisk .

Most importantly, the section https://github.com/JingMatrix/NeoZygisk?tab=readme-ov-file#configuration explictly tells you that you must have Umount modules option on to clean traces.

Dear Jingmatrix, I don't think it's a detection, since the same modules work fine on my other phone, without unmounting modules I can open the same app normally... and it's only vector which trigger that crash, since I disabled all mother modules and started enabling one by one till I found out that enabling vector is the trigger for the crashes. I believe that it's compatibility issue rather than root or xposed detection.

[JingMatrix]

@drandrew1983 Since you have other evidence, please provide logs for me to analyze:
installed debug CI builds of NeoZygisk and Vector, upload the following logs:

1. In your other phone, which you claim that Vector didn't trigger the crash: reboot, open the HSBC US app, and upload the logs.
2. In your current phone: reboot, turn off the Unmount modules option, trigger the crash of HSBC US app, turn on the Unmount modules option, ensure no crash happens, and finally after these steps, upload your logs.

[drandrew1983]

I tried to do that and both phones got stuck on boot screen and not completing boot...
I managed to boot safe mode and then normal mode with all modules disabled on one phone but no luck with the other

[JingMatrix]

@drandrew1983 Maybe there is an issues of overwriting installation. To avoid this, ensure that you uninstall LSPosed (any version) completely, reboot before install Vector.

[drandrew1983]

I don't have lsposed on either of my phones
And one of the phone had soft reset, after so many failed restarts, everything got deleted

[JingMatrix]

@drandrew1983 To debug the issues, please upload the folder /data/adb/lspd/log when you leave safe mode, otherwise it is impossible to help you.

[drandrew1983]

I really appreciate you trying to help, but I can't get my phone to work after installing both debug modules

[JingMatrix]

@drandrew1983 Maybe try other combination? If you are using Magisk, simply use built-in Zygisk first